Tango
Right. Let's see if this works...



Chapter 22 – As You Are


The first thing Erik knew was an extraordinary warmth permeating his entire body, and a dim, infinite sense of peace. He drifted down through the last few moments of near-sleep, drinking in this unexpected gift as greedily as a freakish child whose cage had been left out in the sun. continue reading >>

Комментарии
06.09.2005 в 16:15

Всему свое зелье
Any particular reason to repost it that a humble reader should know about? ;) I found no changes so far (from the ff.net version I read yesterday), but maybe I wasn't attentive enough.

BTW, a very emotionally draining chapter. Everyone is shaken, and so is the reader.)) But can Erik really believe that he can still influence Chrisitne that way, i mean, can't he see that it was her free choice? (or was it?)))
06.09.2005 в 16:47

Tango
Oh, sorry! Nothing like that; Bes just said that he couldn't open the ff.net page for some reason, so I posted it here for him.



But can Erik really believe that he can still influence Christine that way



Why not? She came to him, didn't she? ;) There's his proof right there. He thought that he lost this power because she seemed to be moving on from him, but suddenly -- "oops, I did it again". :D Part of it is arrogance I suppose, in the sense that after influencing her for years he doesn't fully believe in her ability to make her own choices.



i mean, can't he see that it was her free choice? (or was it?)))



I don't think it was, entirely. She did explicitly tell him that she was there because she couldn't help it ('I can't leave!'). And I think they both realise even on the previous night, that it's a profoundly insane thing to do. It's wrong on every level, from the pragmatic to the personal.



So, I think it makes sense that Erik searches for an explanation. Does she love him? Pffft, as if. :D (And besides, she herself gives him no clear indication of this, and I don't think she thinks of it as love). Then what? He considers that she said she couldn't help being there, and also that he did try to pierce through her abandonment himself with the music (that's something I tried to hint at with his angry reflection on the supper, back in Ch 19). So he puts two and two together and makes five, rather like the situation with the Saint-Cloud house: here is a perfectly logical conclusion that happens to be wrong.



As for Christine -- I was trying, in the previous chapter, to convey the sense that the last of her resistance has snapped and she's not acting entirely sensibly. Although she was affected by the music (so Erik isn't completely off-base) what really draws her to him is Erik himself.

But... I'm not sure I'd call it love (yet). It's more like -- they've been messing around with each other's brains for so long that they created a connection, and the harder they try to get away, the stronger it becomes.



Tango
06.09.2005 в 17:02

Всему свое зелье
"Not acting sensibly".. "couldn't help it"... "drawn by him"... "strong connection"... whatever those two + their author think about it, I'd call it love. :gigi: :yes:
06.09.2005 в 17:19

Tango
I'd call it love

Hmm, desire + lack of self-control = love? :lol:



Anyway, of course it's love, otherwise where's the romance. :D But you wouldn't call it "love" if you're 17 and you've been, er, visited by an angel for the better part of the last decade, only to find out out a year ago that he's (among other things) the Phantom, a murderer, a deformed man, and goodness knows how many other things... AND you believe that you love another guy while obviously having weird feelings for this one. I reckon it would be a pretty confusing experience for the poor girl! :)



Tango
06.09.2005 в 17:26

Всему свое зелье
"But you wouldn't call it "love" if you're 17 and.."

- no, no, you're right, I wouldn't. Infact, if I were her I would have already ended up in some nice clean establishment where they tie your arms when you get too agitated. :-D But at least she's tougher. )))
06.09.2005 в 17:36

Tango
Infact, if I were her I would have already ended up in some nice clean establishment where they tie your arms when you get too agitated. But at least she's tougher. )))



You and me both. :D Actually I was writing the previous chapter and thinking that if a guy treated me that way, I'd laugh in his face and get the hell out... But then, if I was in this story, I'd marry Raoul in a heartbeat and live happily ever after. :D (Who needs a freaking lunatic when you can have a nice, normal, attractive guy who loves you to bits?) Of course, that wouldn't make much of a story...



Tango
06.09.2005 в 18:04

Всему свое зелье
:yes: Both literature and day-dreaming would never survive without a Freaking Lunatic, that's for sure. :D
07.09.2005 в 04:33

Tango
Exactly. :D